4
Giacone JA y cols. Hernioplasꢀas inguinales en pacientes de 75 años o mayores. Rev Argent Cir. 2025;117(1):1-7  
El ꢀpo de anestesia uꢀlizado en pacientes año- que la hernioplasꢀa inguinal laparoscópica se asocia  
sos representa un riesgo asociado a la descompensa- a bajas tasas de morbimortalidad y una reducción de  
2
5
ción de enfermedades preexistentes principalmente estadía y costos hospitalarios . En nuestro trabajo,  
pulmonares y cardíacas. Es por eso que se sugiere un en el 60% de los pacientes ≥ 75 años fueron operados  
abordaje mulꢀdisciplinario en la evaluación preopera- por vía laparoscópica. La decisión del ꢀpo de abordaje  
toria de estos pacientes, ya que el manejo efecꢀvo de fue a discreción del cirujano actuante, y los resultados  
estas patologías ayuda a reducir las tasas de complica- fueron similares a los de aquellos operados por vía  
2
1
22  
ciones . En concordancia, Chlebny y cols. observaron convencional. Por lo tanto, el ꢀpo de abordaje para  
un aumento de las complicaciones anestésicas en pa- la reparación de hernia inguinal queda supeditado a  
cientes mayores de 75 años operados de forma urgente la experiencia del equipo quirúrgico y la evaluación  
en comparación con la cirugía elecꢀva. En nuestra serie, mulꢀdisciplinaria preoperatoria.  
los pacientes de 75 años o mayores presentaban ASA III El presente trabajo muestra algunas limitaciones,  
o mayor en más del 20% de los casos, y la gran mayoría principalmente su naturaleza retrospecꢀva. Además,  
de los procedimientos fueron realizados con anestesia nuestra Insꢀtución es un hospital de comunidad  
general. Sin embargo, algunos grupos se han inclinado polivalente y el mayor volumen de atención está  
a indicar anestesia regional e incluso local observando representado por pacientes más jóvenes. A pesar de  
bajas tasas de complicaciones anestésicas asociadas, eso, creemos que podría ser un valioso aporte a la  
sugiriendo este ꢀpo de prácꢀca para pacientes con alto literatura dadas sus fortalezas: el tamaño de la muestra  
2
3
riesgo operatorio . Por lo tanto, la decisión del ꢀpo de y los hallazgos observados.  
anestesia queda a discreción del equipo quirúrgico y de En conclusión, en pacientes de 75 años o mayores,  
una correcta evaluación preoperatoria.  
la hernioplasꢀa inguinal programada es facꢀble y  
Finalmente,quedaclaroqueelꢀpodeanestesiatambién segura, aunque se asocia a mayor morbilidad del siꢀo  
define la técnica quirúrgica, ya que los procedimientos quirúrgico. Por otro lado, este grupo etario requiere  
mininvasivos requieren anestesia general. Como con mayor frecuencia cirugía de urgencia que conlleva  
resultado, la mayoría de los centros uꢀliza técnicas un aumento significaꢀvo de la morbimortalidad. Por  
2
4
convencionales y anestesia locorregional . En un lo tanto, una adecuada evaluación de este grupo de  
estudio sobre una base de datos nacional en Estados pacientes y una reparación en ꢀempo podrían disminuir  
Unidos con 41 937 pacientes, los autores observaron la morbimortalidad asociada.  
■
ENGLISH VERSION  
Introducꢀon  
comorbidiꢀes12,13  
. This age group also has a higher  
number of emergency visits for chronic hernias and  
The ꢀming of IHR in elder paꢀents is variable  
million inguinal hernia repair procedures are and has been the subject of ongoing debate due to the  
1
Inguinal hernias are one of the most common their complicaꢀons.  
surgical condiꢀons and is esꢀmated that approximately  
2
performed annually worldwide . The incidence of the lack of consensus. The aim of this study was to evaluate  
condiꢀon increases with age, being more frequent the results of inguinal hernia repair in paꢀents of 75  
aꢁer age 45. As life expectancy is higher, the incidence years of age or older in our insꢀtuꢀon and to compare  
2
also increases in elder paꢀents . Risk factors include them with the results in younger paꢀents.  
those caused by loss of strength and weakening of  
the abdominal wall ꢀssues and those that increase  
intra-abdominal pressure, such as obesity, chronic Material and methods  
obstrucꢀve pulmonary disease, benign prostaꢀc  
3
hyperplasia and ascites .  
We conducted a retrospecꢀve and comparaꢀve  
Several studies have observed higher morbidity observaꢀonal cohort study by analyzing a consecuꢀve  
and mortality in surgical procedures in the elderly, series of paꢀents undergoing inguinal hernia repair  
4
-6  
especially in those > 80 years . The postoperaꢀve between December 2013 and December 2022. All  
outcomes of elecꢀve inguinal hernia repair (EIHR) the paꢀents were followed up postoperaꢀvely for a  
appear to be similar in young paꢀents compared to minimum of 6 months.  
5
-7  
elderly paꢀents . However, when the procedure is  
The cohort was divided into two groups: < 75  
performed in an emergency seꢂng, some authors years (G1) and ≥ 75 years (G2). Inpaꢀent and outpaꢀent  
have reported a 5 to 15 ꢀmes higher risk of mortality in medical records during the follow-up period were  
8
-12  
paꢀents > 65 years . This parꢀally explains why hernia reviewed. The demographic and perioperaꢀve variables  
repair is not rouꢀnely indicated in elderly paꢀents with and the postoperaꢀve complicaꢀons were evaluated  
Giacone JA y cols. Hernioplasꢀas inguinales en pacientes de 75 años o mayores. Rev Argent Cir. 2025;117(1):1-7  
5
and compared between the two groups. Complicaꢀons  
were categorized using the Clavien-Dindo classificaꢀon.  
The morbidity associated with hernia repair was  
classified as surgical site infecꢀon (SSI), surgical site  
occurrence (SSO) and surgical site occurrence requiring  
procedural intervenꢀons (SSOPIs).  
■
TABLE 2  
Perioperaꢀve variables  
G1 (n=1744) G2 (n=354)  
p
2
Emergency , n (%)  
33 (1.9%)  
29 (9.2%)  
<0.001  
2
Repair  
Quanꢀtaꢀve or conꢀnuous variables were  
Unilateral, n (%)  
Bilateral, n (%)  
1182 (67.8)  
562 (32.2)  
257 (74.5)  
88 (25.5)  
0
.014  
analyzed using the Student’s t test and the chi  
square test was used for qualitaꢀve variables. All the  
calculaꢀons were performed using IBM SPSS Staꢀsꢀcs  
2
Associated procedure , n (%)  
413 (23.7)  
126 (7.2)  
8.4 (±6.2)  
1151 (66)  
99 (±44.4)  
0.3 (±0.2)  
3 (0.17)  
71 (20.6)  
37 (10.7)  
NS  
2
Recurrence , n (%)  
0.02  
3
.0 soꢁware package. Categorical data are expressed  
1
2
Size of the defect , cm (SD)  
15.3 (±8.5) <0.001  
as relaꢀve frequency and conꢀnuous variables as mean  
and standard deviaꢀon except for the follow-up period  
in which median and interquarꢀle range were used.  
2
Laparoscopy , n (%)  
212 (60)  
99 (±40.4)  
0.8 (±1.5)  
3 (0.87)  
NS  
NS  
1
Operaꢀve ꢀme , min (SD)  
1
Length of hospital stay , days (SD)  
<0.001  
2
Criꢀcal care area , n (%)  
0.02  
Results  
SD: standard deviaꢀon. Staꢀsꢀcal tests: 1(Student’s t test); 2 (chi square  
test)  
During the study period, 2739 inguinal hernia  
repair procedures were performed in 2089 paꢀents:  
■
TABLE 3  
6
50 corresponded to bilateral inguinal hernias, 663 to  
Postoperaꢀve variables  
G1 (n=1744) G2 (n=354)  
leꢁ inguinal hernias and 776 to right inguinal hernias. A  
total of 1744 (83.5%) paꢀents were included in G1 and  
p
3
45 in G2 (16.5%). The demographic data are shown in  
1
Follow-up , months (IQR)  
30 (19)  
123 (7)  
30 (12)  
16 (4.6)  
NS  
Table 1.  
2
Overall morbidity , n (%)  
NS  
The perioperaꢀve and postoperaꢀve variables  
that were compared between both groups are  
presented in Tables 2 and 3.  
2
Clavien- Dindo 2b or greater , n (%)  
SSO , n (%)  
SSI , n (%)  
SSOPI , n (%)  
Seroma , n (%)  
Hematoma , n (%)  
Recurrence , n (%)  
Mortality , n (%)  
9 (0.5)  
85 (4.9)  
17 (1)  
5 (0.3)  
39 (2.2)  
34 (1.9)  
17 (0.7)  
0 (0)  
6 (1.7)  
30 (8.7)  
4 (1.1)  
6 (1.7)  
13 (3.8)  
11 (3.2)  
3 (0.7)  
2 (0.6)  
0.01  
0.004  
NS  
0.001  
NS  
NS  
NS  
0.03  
2
Two paꢀents died. Both paꢀents were in  
2
G2 and presented strangulated hernias requiring  
emergency surgery (G1: 0% vs. G2: 0.5%; p = 0.03). Both  
cases were inguinoscrotal hernias that had never been  
evaluated by a surgeon before, and death occurred  
within 24 hours of surgery. One paꢀent had a history  
of rheumaꢀc disease requiring corꢀcosteroids and  
developed respiratory failure secondary to aspiraꢀon  
pneumonia. The other paꢀents with no relevant history  
developed sepꢀc shock secondary to intesꢀnal necrosis.  
2
2
2
2
2
IQR: interquarꢀle range; SSO: surgical site occurrence; SSOPI: surgical site  
occurrence requiring procedural intervenꢀon. Staꢀsꢀcal tests: 1(Student’s  
t test); 2 (chi square test).  
Discussion  
■
TABLE 1  
Nowadays, the difference between biological  
age and chronological age is clear. As a result, we are  
increasingly performing more complex surgeries on  
older adults or elder paꢀents. Convenꢀonally, the World  
Health Organizaꢀon (WHO) has defined older adults as  
Demographic variables  
G1 (n=1744)  
55 (±13)  
G2 (n=354)  
p
<0.001  
NS  
1
Age , years (SD)  
80 (± 4.4)  
304: 41  
2
Sex , (M:F)  
1568: 176  
25.6 (±5.3)  
244 (14%)  
14  
individuals aged 65 years or older . However, data for  
1
2
BMI , kg/m (SD)  
25.3 (±5.2)  
32 (9.3%)  
NS  
the year 2023 presented by the Pan American Health  
Organizaꢀon (PAHO) indicate that the current age of an  
older adult is 78 years, represenꢀng a 4.1-year increase  
2
Smoking , n (%)  
NS  
2
ASA grade  
1
/2, n (%)  
/4, n (%)  
1684 (96.5)  
60 (3.5)  
272 (78.8)  
73 (21.2)  
15  
<0.001  
compared with the year 2000 . While chronological  
3
age alone does not appear to be a determining factor to  
indicate the procedure, its use as a cut-off point would  
SD: standard deviaꢀon; BMI: body mass index. ASA: American Society of  
Anesthesiologists. Staꢀsꢀcal tests: 1(Student’s t test); 2 (chi square test)  
6
Giacone JA y cols. Hernioplasꢀas inguinales en pacientes de 75 años o mayores. Rev Argent Cir. 2025;117(1):1-7  
allow for an adequate evaluaꢀon of the sample under in terms of chronic pain and recurrence rate. These  
study. Based on this concept, we consider that age 75 is observaꢀons confirm that, despite a higher morbidity  
an appropriate cut-off point for our study.  
Decision-making in paꢀents 75 years of a reliable alternaꢀve for this group of paꢀents.  
age or older with inguinal hernia, who usually have The type of anesthesia used in elderly paꢀents  
rate, inguinal hernia repair in specialized centers is sꢀll  
comorbidiꢀes, requires the assessment of several represents an associated risk of decompensaꢀon  
factors to improve outcomes. The present study of pre-exisꢀng pulmonary and cardiac diseases. For  
observed that paꢀents aged 75 years or older with this reason, the preoperaꢀve assessment of these  
inguinal hernia exhibited a higher incidence of the paꢀents requires a mulꢀdisciplinary approach, since  
following: a) emergency surgery, b) postoperaꢀve the effecꢀve management of these condiꢀons helps to  
2
1
22  
surgical site complicaꢀons, and c) mortality associated reduce complicaꢀon rates . Chlebny et al. observed  
with inguinal hernia repair. an increase in anestheꢀc complicaꢀons in paꢀents  
It seems to be clear that inguinal hernia repair older than 75 years undergoing emergency surgery  
is associated with increased morbidity in these paꢀents. compared with elecꢀve surgery. In our series, more  
However, the decision not to perform surgery should be than 20% of paꢀents aged 75 years or older were  
made with extreme cauꢀon, as this age group is more classified as ASA grade 3 or higher and most procedures  
likely to require emergency surgery, which is associated were performed under general anesthesia. However,  
with high morbidity and mortality. Accordingly, in some groups preferred to use regional or even local  
our series, paꢀents aged 75 years or older were 4 anesthesia and reported low rates of associated  
ꢀ
mes more likely to undergo emergency surgery, and anestheꢀc complicaꢀons, suggesꢀng this type of  
23  
mortality only occurred in this group. This has also pracꢀce for paꢀents at high surgical risk . Therefore,  
been observed by other authors5-11 who emphasize the the decision of the type of anesthesia is leꢁ to the  
need for appropriate evaluaꢀon by the surgical team. discreꢀonofthesurgicalteamandaproperpreoperaꢀve  
In addiꢀon, considering that inguinal hernias have few evaluaꢀon.  
symptoms and a low complicaꢀon rate in general, it is  
reasonable to assume that conservaꢀve management also determines the surgical technique, as minimally  
Finally, it is clear that the type of anesthesia  
1
6
(
watchful waiꢀng) may be appropriate . In our invasive procedures require general anesthesia. As  
experience, aꢁer implemenꢀng this protocol in 100 a result, most centers use convenꢀonal techniques  
2
4
paꢀents, we observed a crossover rate of 50% within and locoregional anesthesia . A study on a naꢀonal  
2 months of follow-up, with pain and age > 75 years database in the United States with 41,937 paꢀents  
5
1
7
as independent factors for the need for surgery . Van revealed that laparoscopic inguinal hernia repair is  
1
8
den Dop et al. reported a crossover rate of 64% aꢁer associated with low morbidity and mortality rates,  
2 years and an incarceraꢀon rate of 3.9%. Therefore, as well as a reducꢀon in length of hospital stay and  
1
2
5
several variables should be considered to achieve an hospital costs . In our study, 60% of paꢀents ≥ 75 years  
appropriate management in this group of paꢀents. If underwent laparoscopic surgery. The decision on the  
watchful waiꢀng is decided, it should be implemented type of approach was at the discreꢀon of the treaꢀng  
in a referral center for abdominal wall surgery with a surgeon, and the results were similar to those achieved  
clearly defined protocol for follow-up and taking into using the convenꢀonal approach. Therefore, the type  
account that paꢀents > 65 years have a greater need for of approach for inguinal hernia repair depends on the  
1
6
surgery compared with younger adults .  
It is important to emphasize that paꢀents mulꢀdisciplinary evaluaꢀon.  
5 years of age or older usually present with chronic The present study has some limitaꢀons  
experience of the surgical team and the preoperaꢀve  
7
and large inguinal hernias and symptoms that affect mainly due to its retrospecꢀve nature. Furthermore,  
quality of life. This may parꢀally explain the higher our insꢀtuꢀon is a mulꢀspecialty community hospital,  
frequency of emergency surgery and higher rates with the highest volume of care provided to younger  
of surgical site complicaꢀons. For example, Akeel19 paꢀents. Nevertheless, because of the sample size and  
found that paꢀents aged 60 years or older undergoing our findings, the strengths of our study, we believe it  
elecꢀve hernia repair had significantly higher rates of could be a valuable contribuꢀon to the literature.  
wound complicaꢀons, such as seroma and hematoma,  
In conclusion, elecꢀve inguinal hernia repair  
compared with paꢀents younger than 60 years. In a is a feasible and safe surgical opꢀon for paꢀents  
recent systemaꢀc review by Piltcher-da-Silva et al.20 aged 75 years and older, although it is associated  
in elderly paꢀents undergoing emergency inguinal with an increased risk of surgical site complicaꢀons.  
hernia repair, the authors observed a postoperaꢀve This age group is more likely to require emergency  
complicaꢀon rate of 21-29% and a mortality rate of surgery, resulꢀng in a significant increase in morbidity  
1
.2-6%. In our series, paꢀents ≥ 75 years had a higher and mortality. Therefore, proper evaluaꢀon of this  
percentage of SSOs and SSOPIs; however, this did paꢀent populaꢀon and ꢀmely repair could reduce the  
not seem to affect the mid- and long-term outcome associated morbidity and mortality.  
Giacone JA y cols. Hernioplasꢀas inguinales en pacientes de 75 años o mayores. Rev Argent Cir. 2025;117(1):1-7  
7
Referencias bibliográficas /References  
1
2
3
4
.
.
.
.
Kingsnorth A, LeBlanc K. Hernias: inguinal and incisional. Lancet.  
003;362:561-71.  
Arias E. US life tables, 2008. Naꢀonal Vital Staꢀsꢀcs Reports. 2012;  
1(3).  
14. Orimo H, Ito H, Suzuki T, Araki A, Hosoi T, Sawabe M. Reviewing  
the definiꢀon of “elderly”. Geriatr Gerontol Int. 2006;6(3):149-58.  
15. OPS. Perfil de País: Argenꢀna. En: hꢃps://hia.paho.org/es/  
paises-2022/perfil-argenꢀna; consultado el 28/02/2024.  
16. Schroeder AD, Tubre DJ, Fitzgibbons RJ Jr. Watchful Waiꢀng for  
Inguinal Hernia. Adv Surg. 2019;53:293-303.  
2
6
Maꢃhew RD, Neumayer L. Inguinal hernia in the 21st century: an  
evidence-based review. Curr Probl Surg. 2008; 45:261-312.  
Hamel MD, Henderson WG, Khuri SF, Daley J. Surgical outcomes  
for paꢀents age 80 and older: morbidity and mortality from non-  
cardiac surgery. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2005; 53:424-9.  
17. Sadava EE, Angeramo CA, Dreifuss NH, Murdoch Duncan N,  
Schloꢃmann F. Manejo conservador (mirar y esperar) en pacientes  
con hernia inguinal asintomáꢀca u oligosintomáꢀca. Facꢀbilidad  
y resultados a largo plazo de un centro de alto volumen en  
Laꢀnoamérica. Rev Hispanoam Hernia. 2023;11(3):105-10.  
18. Van den Dop LM, Van Egmond S, Heijne J, Van Rosmalen J, de  
Goede B, Wijsmuller AR, et al. Twelve-year outcomes of watchful  
waiꢀng versus surgery of mildly symptomaꢀc or asymptomaꢀc  
inguinal hernia in men aged 50 years and older: a randomised  
controlled trial. E Clinical Medicine. 2023; 64:102207.  
5
.
Tjeertes EKM, Simoncelli TFW, van den Enden AJM, Maꢃace-  
Raso FUS, Stolker RJ, Hoeks SE. Perioperaꢀve outcome, long-term  
mortality and ꢀme trends in elderly paꢀents undergoing low-,  
intermediate- or major non-cardiac surgery. Aging Clin Exp Res.  
2
024;36(1):64.  
6
7
8
9
1
1
1
1
.
.
.
.
van Heesewijk AE, Lammerts RGM, Haveman JW, Meerdink M,  
van Leeuwen BL, Pol RA. Outcome aꢁer cholecystectomy in the  
elderly. Am J Surg. 2019;218(2): 368-73.  
19. Akeel N. Short-Term Outcomes of Inguinal Hernia Repair in Older  
Paꢀents: A Retrospecꢀve Review at a Terꢀary Center. Cureus.  
2021;13(9):e18170.  
Nilsson H, Styliandidis G, Haapama¨ki M, Nilsson E, Nordin P.  
Mortality aꢁer groin hernia surgery. Ann Surg. 2007;245(4):656-  
6
0.  
20. Piltcher-da-Silva R, Sasaki VL, Beꢂni LFC, Soares PSM, Valandro IG,  
Cavazzola LT. Outcomes of Emergency Groin Hernia Repair in the  
Elderly: A Systemaꢀc Review. J Abdom Wall Surg. 2023;2:11246.  
21. Griffiths R, Beech F, Brown A, Dhesi J, Foo I, Goodall J, et al. Peri-  
operaꢀve care of the elderly 2014: Associaꢀon of Anaestheꢀsts of  
Great Britain and Ireland. Anaesthesia. 2014;69(1):81-98.  
22. Chlebny T, Zelga P, Pryt M, Zelga M, Dziki A. Safe and  
uncomplicated inguinal hernia surgery in the elderly - message  
from anesthesiologists to general surgeons. Pol Przegl Chir.  
2017;89(2):5-10.  
Pallaꢀ PK, Gupta PK, Bichala S, Gupta H, Fang X, Forse RA. Short-  
term outcomes of inguinal hernia repair in octogenarians and  
nonagenarians. Hernia. 2013;17 (6):723-7.  
Abi-Haidar Y, Sánchez V, Itani K. Risk factors and outcomes  
of acute versus elecꢀve groin hernia surgery. J Am Coll Surg.  
2
011;213(3):363-9.  
0. Kulah B, Duzgun AP, Moran M, Kulacoglu IH, Ozmen MM, Coskun  
F. Emergency hernia repairs in elderly paꢀents. Am J Surg.  
2
001;182:455-9.  
1. Primatesta P, Goldacre MJ. Inguinal hernia repair: incidence of  
elecꢀve and emergency surgery, readmission and mortality. Int J  
Epidemiol. 1996;25(4):835-9.  
23. Nienhuijs SW, Remijn EEG, Rosman C. Hernia repair in elderly  
paꢀents under unmonitored local anaesthesia is feasible. Hernia.  
2005; 9:218-22.  
2. O’Dwyer PJ, Norrie J, Alani A, Walker A, Duffy F, Horgan P.  
Observaꢀon or operaꢀon for paꢀents with an asymptomaꢀc  
inguinal hernia. Ann Surg. 2006; 244(2):167-73.  
24. HerniaSurge Group. Internaꢀonal guidelines for groin hernia  
management. Hernia. 2018;22(1):1-165.  
25. Pérez AJ, Strassle PD, Sadava EE, Gaber C, Schloꢃmann F.  
Naꢀonwide Analysis of Inpaꢀent Laparoscopic Versus Open  
InguinalHerniaRepair.JLaparoendoscAdvSurgTechA.2020;30(3):  
292-8.  
3. Fitzgibbons RJ Jr, Biobbie-Hurder A, Gibbs J, Dunlop DD, Reda DJ,  
McCarthy M Jr, et al. Watchful waiꢀng versus repair of inguinal  
herniainminimallysymptomaꢀcmen. JAMA. 2006;295(3):285-92.