Gasque RA y cols. Revistas depredadoras: ¿qué saben los cirujanos generales? . Rev Argent Cir. 2025;117(2):e-1838
7
Canadian academic surgeon, and found that, of 1905 result in an underesꢀmaꢀon or overesꢀmaꢀon of the
emails, 608 (31.92%) were idenꢀꢂed as fraudulent knowledge and experiences menꢀoned.
1
2
phishing emails from predatory publishers or journals .
These data allow us to infer the following: sample consisted of surgeons between the ages of 30
Finally, it is noteworthy that 61.11% of the
1
) idenꢀfying predatory journals is challenging and
and 50. While we did not conduct a speciꢂc subanalysis
in this age group, the implementaꢀon of conꢀnuing
educaꢀon programs targeted at general surgeons
especially at the beginning of their academic careers
to train them in the idenꢀꢂcaꢀon and prevenꢀon of
predatory journals is crucial. Ideally, these iniꢀaꢀves
should be incorporated into the insꢀtuꢀonal policies
of academic insꢀtuꢀons with the aim of protecꢀng
scienꢀꢂc integrity and honesty.
represents a cross-cuꢃng concern in many medical
disciplines, 2) speciꢂc knowledge about these
journals is highly variable and heterogeneous among
professionals, and 3) specialized training signiꢂcantly
improves idenꢀꢂcaꢀon skills. This prompts the
following quesꢀon: how can surgeons avoid becoming
vicꢀms of predatory journals? Unfortunately, there is no
1
3
global consensus on how to deal with these journals .
Nevertheless, there are some useful ꢀps and resources
listed in Table 3.
Future lines of research will be necessary to
invesꢀgate the impact of these publicaꢀons on the
academic trajectory in order to develop educaꢀonal
intervenꢀons and new idenꢀꢂcaꢀon tools.
Our study has some strengths and limitaꢀons.
One strength is the inclusion of a diverse sample of
general surgeons from Argenꢀna, which allows us
to obtain an iniꢀal approach to the knowledge and
aꢃtudes towards predatory journals. In addiꢀon,
the use of an anonymous survey promotes honest
responses. Yet, the study design may introduce biases
that limit the generalizability of the results. The number
of parꢀcipants was small and the survey was not
Conclusion
This study demonstrates a signiꢂcant lack
of awareness and difficulty in idenꢀfying predatory
distributed through the official networks of Asociación journals among general surgeons in Argenꢀna.
Argenꢀna de Cirugía or its regional affiliates. As a While there is a prevalent aꢃtude of ignorance and
result, the sample of surgeons in the country is quite uncertainty, most parꢀcipants acknowledged the
limited. Addiꢀonally, relying solely on self-reporꢀng can signiꢂcance of being informed about this threat.
■
TABLE 3
Tips and resources for idenꢀfying predatory journals
Resources to idenꢀfy them
Suggesꢀve features
Misleading geographic informaꢀon about the journal’s headquarters Beall’s list*
Rapid peer-review and publicaꢀon processes
Arꢀcle processing charge is very low
Titles are long and cumbersome
Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ)†
Cabell’s Internaꢀonal Directory‡
Think.Check.Submit Iniꢀaꢀve§
PubMed Journal List¶
Web of Science**
Mulꢀple and repeated emails in overly flaꢄering manner.
Short submission deadlines
Author’s training and educaꢀon by scienꢀꢂc socieꢀes and their official
False use of logos (e.g. COPE or ICMJE)
publishing organs
Unusually high impact factors or suspicious metrics
Fake or inexistent ISSN
Laꢀndex system††
Scienꢀꢂc Electronic Library Online (SciELO)‡‡
Blog Flaky Academic Journals§§
Grammaꢀcal and spelling errors with unprofessional design
Access links: *hꢄps://beallslist.net/ | †hꢄps://doaj.org/ | ‡hꢄps://cabells.com/ | §hꢄps://thinkchecksubmit.org/ | ¶hꢄps://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/
nlmcatalog/journals/ | **hꢄps://mjl.clarivate.com/home | ††hꢄps://laꢀndex.org/laꢀndex/ | ‡‡hꢄps://scielo.org/ | §§hꢄps://flakyj.blogspot.com/
Referencias bibliográficas /References
1
2
.
.
Gast KM, Kuzon WM Jr, Waljee JF. Bibliometric indices and
academic promoꢀon within plasꢀc surgery. Plast Reconstr Surg.
et al. Publicaꢀon Inaccuracies Listed in General Surgery Residency
Training Program Applicaꢀons. J Am Coll Surg. 2021;233(4):545-
53. DOI: 10.1016/j.jamcollsurg.2021.07.002.
2
014;134:838e–844e. DOI: 10.1097/PRS.0000000000000594.
Shamseer L, Moher D, Maduekwe O, Turner L, Barbour V, Burch R,
et al. Potenꢀal predatory and legiꢀmate biomedical journals: can
you tell the difference? A cross-secꢀonal comparison. BMC Med.
4. Cohen AJ, Paꢀno G, Kamal P, Ndoye M, Tresh A, Mena J, et
al. Perspecꢀves From Authors and Editors in the Biomedical
Disciplines on Predatory Journals: Survey Study. J Med Internet
Res. 2019;21(8):e13769. DOI: 10.2196/13769.
2
017;15(1):28. DOI: 10.1186/s12916-017-0785-9.
3
.
Yeh DD, Reynolds JM, Pust GD, Sleeman D, Meizoso JP, Menzel C,
5. Marꢀnino A, Puri O, Pereira JPS, Owen E, Chaꢄerjee S,